As a suggestion and to probably add clarification .....
Let's rename this as Photoshop Challenge QUARTET - Round (1) ..... consisting of 4 randomly (or forcibly chosen .... lol ) members.
In other forums, such a challenge consists of 2 participants . Here at PSG , we add a different twist - we have FOUR MEMBERS going head to head. The rest of the members are there to give critique to each participant's image and give their VOTE to who should be the winner. BCVISUALS will tabulate the FINAL results.
As in other forums, the objective is NOT to determine who is the better guy. But a chance to showcase the different styles and possibilities that can be used to manipulate, enhance or compose an image. In this way, the non-participating viewers get to train their eye to detect what procedure/s or effect/s were used to achieve the image as well as honing their skill in giving critique.
In short the challenge is a lesson for everyone including the participants.
Will this be a weekly challenge or bi-monthly thing (twice a month) ?
We have to agree on a Date and Time to open and end the challenge . I suggest a Saturday as opening date. And given a time limit of 72 hours.
BCVISUALS..... since this is your baby, shall we use your time zone (Eastern Time) as basis? Or GMT? What time should it start ?
My next question is... Who will select the next 4 challengers for the next Round? To give time for them to settle down from the shock of being chosen, they should be notified 3 days before the next round.
just my 2 sens....