my edit. suggestions please from everyone for better

[one_1]

please all suggestons are welcomed

 

[Eggy]

It is hard and kind of brownish...
You had a request I did for you. That one looks way more natural.

 

[one_1]

your work is so good too do you suggest my editing more soft and not vey hard?

 

[one_1]

the second half of the photo according to me is very bright

 

[Eggy]

the second half of the photo according to me is very bright

You provided of photo that was backlit and asked for a sunset.
There are many ways to edit a photo but mine was as close as possible to reality.
Of course opinions vary...but your version is a bit hard and not very natural.

BTW, what do you mean by 'the second half of the photo according to me is very bright'?

 

[one_1]

You provided of photo that was backlit and asked for a sunset.
There are many ways to edit a photo but mine was as close as possible to reality.
Of course opinions vary...but your version is a bit hard and not very natural.

BTW, what do you mean by 'the second half of the photo according to me is very bright'?

your editing is so nice but I prefer more colorful phtoso. tastes are tastes for everyone . i mean the part of the sea , very brught according to my opinion

 

[Eggy]

Unless requested otherwise I always try to go for the natural way.
But of course taste differ...

 

[IamSam]

Hello.

Coloration is of course up to an individuals personal taste. I for one think that your image has a bit too much unnatural violet coloration in the foreground that's in direct contradiction with the backgrounds (sky) lighting.

The brightness of this area needs to be addressed.


The cloud cover would extend all the way to the horizon. You have a greyish colored sky and a blown out bright white/purple horizon.

 

[one_1]

Hello.

Coloration is of course up to an individuals personal taste. I for one think that your image has a bit too much unnatural violet coloration in the foreground that's in direct contradiction with the backgrounds (sky) lighting.

The brightness of this area needs to be addressed.
View attachment 84771

The cloud cover would extend all the way to the horizon. You have a greyish colored sky and a blown out bright white/purple horizon.

thnks guys for all your opinions

 

[Argos]

As i said to you, is not only a matter of color, is change the tipe and direction of light and if you want a sunset in this photo you have to change alsmot everything...

I made rought sketch with bad selections and alot of mistakes, but i think its understandable what i mean

 

[one_1]

As i said to you, is not only a matter of color, is change the tipe and direction of light and if you want a sunset in this photo you have to change alsmot everything...

I made rought sketch with bad selections and alot of mistakes XD, but i think its understandable what i

greAT man ! understand your thoughts ! how did you color the sea? by painting?

 

[one_1]

using gradient custom color?

 

[Argos]

greAT man ! understand your thoughts ! how did you color the sea? by painting?

kinda, i just selected the sea. painted the selection in a new layer using the color of the sky and use the blend mode subexpose color, i used this metod two or three time for the diferent zones of the sea.

Cheers!