Reply to thread

I think you've done a good job with the perspective, colors and lighting. But in my opinion what still needs work is the fact that the 'pontoon' should contain greater focus and detail in the foreground than in the background. Your's, at the moment, is the other way around---the pontoon gets sharper as it recedes.

 I did a quick experiment to see if an idea would work. I queried Google for images of a Boardwalk (do you use that term in the UK?) and found the image immediately below. I pasted it into your image and then did the following:

1. Convert the boardwalk layer to black & white.

2. Apply a layer mask to correctly fit the wooden portion within your marina image and mask-out the rest. I ignored the blue-colored areas for now and only focused on the orange-ish areas.

3. I took your original image and copied the wooden portion to a new layer above the B&W boardwalk layer. Then I changed the layer blend mode to Hard Light to restore the colors and shadows (Vivid Light and Linear Light also gave interesting results).

My final result is the second image below. I did this very quickly and wasn't being very careful, but it's one possible way to add some texture and detail to the foreground.

[ATTACH]72531[/ATTACH]

[ATTACH]72532[/ATTACH]