Reply to thread

The only thing I find "wrong" is why you seem to doubt what you've done so far when you've actually replicated it as close as possibly can.

When designing something, at least give yourself the conviction and pride that what you created is good - be it a replicated look or a fresh twist to an existing format (the latter being better).

You've replicated it and nothing's wrong with it. Now ask yourself this question.... Is there something else I can do to improve on it and make it better than the original? Find that answer and you've got something that you can call your own design.

Just to add...  If there's something wrong with it, it could be in the hierarchy of layers in the psd. I could be wrong since I don't do web design tho I've heard that final composition should be done in a web design application and that a PS design may not necessarily work in a web design application setting..

 Only the web designers here can be the judge of this.