Before/after of a photo edit

[5600k]

Here is a before/after of a photograph im playing around with.


Would love to know your thoughts or what you'd do different to improve the original picture.

 

[Jessicayla]

I think you did an excellent job. The green is a really nice shade, the sky looks good.. *clap*

 

[Natalie007]

Nice job, love the sky you added

 

[5600k]

I think you did an excellent job. The green is a really nice shade, the sky looks good.. *clap*

Nice job, love the sky you added

Thank you Jessicayla & Natalie007. Im glad you liked it

 

[digitaltwist]

Awesome job. Do you know where that photo was taken? Looks like fun.

 

[Paul]

Nice job done, one small issue the font on the cable car should have been isolated, it has over saturated when you did the green effect.

 

[///Audience]

the edit looks amazing! Did you take the original photograph? It looks like a gondola to heaven.

 

[5600k]

Awesome job. Do you know where that photo was taken? Looks like fun.

Thanks digitaltwist! It was heaps of fun.. Taken at Langkawi in Malaysia.

Nice job done, one small issue the font on the cable car should have been isolated, it has over saturated when you did the green effect.

Thanks Paul.. and yeah youre right it probably went a little too bright and saturated while i went about ccing the whole image.

the edit looks amazing! Did you take the original photograph? It looks like a gondola to heaven.

Thanks ///Audience. Glad you liked it. And yes i did take the original photograph. Its a beautiful place. You should go sometime.

 

[AlexandraR]

great job

 

[5600k]

great job

Thank you AlexandraR. Glad you liked it.

 

[Pepperbel]

It is a good edit, in terms of contrast and such things.

I personally quite like the dark lighting in the original photo, I know it's down to personal taste, and I might be a bit sadistic in my colour choices, but as I said, in terms of editing it's really well done, however I personally think that the whole mist/cloud dynamic that's going on gives it more of a dark and mysterious feel and the blue sky makes it look very happy.

If you were going for a brighter edit, then ignore me.

Otherwise, here's a very quickly done edit of what I mean:

 

[Narnaxx]

Brilliant.

 

[Daniela]

neat retouch!

 

[xversion1]

Great job!

 

[braderz999]

I like the pic! The original as well as yours both are great images, I like how the original has a mysterious gloomy tone, whilst yours yours is something with more life like you would see in a jurassic park movie

One thing to critique I would say a noise reduction may have benefited it as there is a bit of noise in there, other than that great!