Photo Manipulation Smartphone

[SMOk3]

All critique welcome.

 

[IamSam]

Very nice work! Thanks for sharing.

It's not a critique, because I think it looks fine the way it is, but I might have done away with the rocks (below the thumb) and just had the waterfall going to the bottom.

 

[polarwoc]

All critique welcome.

A wonderful composition. I love the way you cut out the waterfall and left it flowing out of the phone screen, giving the illusion of 3D. I agree with @IamSam. The rocks end abruptly eventhough you gave them a nice feathered finish. Either they should have 1) had their natural edge or 2) continued until the bottom of the photo or 3) waterfall should have been the finishing point like it is on the left side.