2 versions of same picture, which is better?

[Vetoed]

Which one is better?





or




Thanks

 

[RTContent]

Neither is better as the design is simple and effective. It works both ways so it really depends on what would be more consistent with the idea of the music. Primarily dark or light?

R

 

[ibclare]

I think the second with the dark background has more impact. I would like to see more of the texture, a little more contrast.

 

[Vetoed]

Neither is better as the design is simple and effective. It works both ways so it really depends on what would be more consistent with the idea of the music. Primarily dark or light?

R

The chorus on this song is amazing tbh girls voice is perfect

 

[Inkz]

I prefer the black text to be honest. I'm guessing so correct me if I'm wrong but the barbed wire going down the sword needs more work. In the white text version it looks like Christmas tree lights.

 

[ibclare]

I agree on the bared wire. It's fuzzy and it could be larger in contrast to the sword. Regarding the black letters, the grey background disturbs me. Why not just white? Anyway, I think it's a personal choice on which one is better.

 

[Vetoed]

I agree with the barbed wire thing, it was a last second throw in. Now that I think about it I could have made it look a whole lot better lol

 

[Jessicayla]

I like the second one a bit better. It pops out more.

 

[Paul]

Just an idea.
:mrgreen:

 

[3deffect]

well second one pic is better....and putting green is not look good at all..try out yellow...may be yellow looks great

 

[Paul]

Goes with the name mate, just an idea

 

[3deffect]

well its my suggestion only...mate...and i know 2d,3d,vfx knowledge...so i put the name 3deffct....and its a global name:mrgreen:

 

[agentmoeller]

Black background is much better, as it shows some of the texture, where the white shows almost none.

Agent

 

[Rob_IMX]

I like the second.. more texture than just the white background

 

[PsychedelicPanda]

I would prefer the second one. White text with the dark background looks effective. I would suggest you to work little more with the sword, especially with the barber wire. The spikes could be little more sharper. I think the text should stay white. Good job!

 

[Paul]

well its my suggestion only...mate...and i know 2d,3d,vfx knowledge...so i put the name 3deffct....and its a global name:mrgreen:

Good for you, got any work to show us rubbish members how it is done?